Here’s a detailed comparison between Quick Redirects & 404 and SC Easy Redirects Shopify apps to help you choose the best solution for managing redirects and fixing 404 errors.
1. Overview
Feature
Quick Redirects & 404
SC Easy Redirects
App Purpose
Manage 301/302 redirects, fix 404 errors.
Automate and manage bulk redirects & 404 errors.
Best For
Shopify stores needing flexible redirects.
Stores with large product catalogs & migration needs.
Ease of Use
User-friendly with bulk options & patterns.
Simple UI with automated features for ease.
Customization
Advanced patterns (wildcards, dynamic URLs).
Automated redirects based on 404 logs.
2. Redirect Management
Feature
Quick Redirects & 404
SC Easy Redirects
Bulk Import/Export
✅ Supports CSV import/export.
✅ Supports CSV import/export.
Redirect Types
✅ Supports 301 (permanent) & 302 (temporary).
✅ Supports 301 and 302 redirects.
Dynamic Redirects (Wildcards)
✅ Supports wildcard redirects (e.g., /old/*).
✅ Support for advanced patterns.
Auto Redirects
✅ Automatically detects 404s
✅ Automatically detects & suggests redirects.
SEO-Friendly Redirects
✅ Ensures SEO-safe redirections.
✅ SEO-first redirects to avoid ranking drops.
404 Error Tracking
✅ Logs & identifies 404 errors for manual fixing.
✅ Automatically tracks and fixes 404s.
3. Advanced Features
Feature
Quick Redirects & 404
SC Easy Redirects
Redirect Patterns
✅ Supports advanced URL mapping & patterns.
✅ Basic to advanced redirect patterns only.
Duplicate Redirects Check
✅ Identifies & prevents redirect duplication.
✅ Auto-checks for duplicate entries.
Redirect Analytics
✅ Tracks redirect hits & performance.
✅ Logs redirect actions & outcomes.
Redirect Chain Prevention
✅ Avoids multiple redirect loops
✅ Automatically resolves redirect chains.
Custom Rules
✅ Create redirect rules for collections, pages, etc.
✅ No limitation customization for rules.
4. Pricing
Plan Type
Quick Redirects & 404
SC Easy Redirects
Free Plan
✅ Available (limited redirects).
✅ Available (limited redirects).
Paid Plan
✅ Flexible pricing based on redirect volume.
✅ Tiered pricing based on store size.
Best Value
✅ Best for advanced manual control & flexibility.
✅ Best for automated redirect management.
5. Support & Documentation
Support Feature
Quick Redirects & 404
SC Easy Redirects
Customer Support
✅ Email & live chat.
✅ Email support only.
Help Documentation
✅ Detailed setup & troubleshooting guides.
✅ Clear but basic knowledge base.
Customization Support
✅ Supports advanced custom redirect needs.
✅ Allow to default automation.
6. Pros & Cons
Quick Redirects & 404
Pros:
Full control over custom redirects (manual & patterns).
Supports advanced patterns & wildcards.
Suitable for stores needing precise redirect mapping.
Prevent duplicate redirects and chains.
Cons:
No auto-suggestions for 404s
Requires manual work for large-scale stores.
SC Easy Redirects
Pros:
Auto-detects 404 errors and suggests fixes.
Easy bulk management via CSV.
Ideal for stores migrating from other platforms.
Cons:
Limited customization options for advanced redirect needs.
Less control over manual redirect patterns.
Which One Should You Choose?
1. Choose Quick Redirects & 404 if:
You need manual control advanced patterns
You want to prevent redirect chains duplicates
You manage complex URL structures (e.g., product migrations).
2. Choose SC Easy Redirects if:
You want automated 404 detection and quick fixes.
You’re migrating to a large store and need bulk redirects
